JAGzilla wrote: ↑Sat Jul 20, 2024 7:13 am
Or you could flip it around: people who don't find Godzilla and kaiju relatable or engaging but
do like skate culture might be tempted to pick this up.
The fact that the
Skate or Die Thread is one of the deadest/least active comic threads of any recent G comic in memory speaks volumes.
"What does the Coin Toss mean to you?"...apparently not much to readers. It's just too narrow of a niche (Australian skater punk culture) to drag out over 5 issues with Godzilla, nor is it going to bring in a significant amount of new fans to Godzilla.
I 100% agree about
History's Greatest Monster (I was just as hard on that series back then as I am on some of IDW's recent stinkers), which along with
Skate or Die both suck in their own unique ways (Very curious/odd comparison though).
They're expanding their customer base and potentially winning some converts.
Yeah, that huge Great Gatsby niche in the comic collecting community will draw in big numbers for a Godzilla mini
As long as the story is engaging, I'm all in. But let's not kid ourselves here about this being a potential "huge" draw/lure for non-G films.
Established Godzilla fans might roll their eyes and gripe, but of course will still buy any new product Toho puts in front of them.
While the usual "
Everything Godzilla is good!" crowd definitely will, many others probably won't.
Angilasman wrote: ↑Sat Jul 20, 2024 8:44 am
Is it just me or is that image of Jay Gatsby based off the old Doc Savage movie poster?
Yes, it's obvious he's trying to do the "retro 60s-70s" throwback/nostalgia art style that's been quite popular lately (it's been a bit overdone the last few years in comic industry in general imho.). I'm fine/indifferent with this art style choice...it's just his artwork of Godzilla himself which I find ugly and off-putting. Sue me
Jetty_Jags wrote: ↑Sat Jul 20, 2024 7:15 am
Have you ever considered that the reason there are so many IDW godzilla comics with vastly different premises might simply
be to target vastly different niche's and get them individually related in godzilla properties rather than continually appeal to the "general G comic audience"? Of course you're right, outlandish ideas don't mean good stories, but comics are the medium to do weird stuff in, and I think the kind of scatter ball method IDW is employing is quite interesting. Sure I won't pick up everything they have but there's plenty of variety that I find some of it interesting enough to check out. At least, I'm far more interested in a godzilla v varen story backdropped against punk skaters than para-millitary 80s action crew of their 2012 ongoing run, and I'm neither a punk nor a skater.
"Outlandish" ideas are fine when they're well-executed....when not done well, however, they can bring quite a bit of inconsistency to these books as a whole. For every "wild" concept such as
HTBD/GvsMMPR1, there seem to be 3-4 very mediocre/underwhelming minis as well. I just think IDW needs to think and plan some of these "wild" concepts out a bit more overall in terms of producing a quality product before just letting some of these writers "go nuts"...
Moth wrote: ↑Wed Jul 24, 2024 9:31 pm
If Godzilla is drawn in a distinct art style? YUCK!
The predictable go-to
"You just don't like anything outside the box and aren't open to different ideas! Waaaah!" argument that many automatically turn to whenever any G comic/film/toy/etc. isn't 100% embraced is all fine and dandy....but the Bottomline is simple: If it looks like shit, smells like shit, then it's most likely shit....the chosen art style is irrelevant (Same goes for writing), and I'll continue to call some of these comics out on it, regardless of the usual backlash.
If Godzilla is traced? YUCK!
Yup, I despise traced artwork and artists who trace/plagiarize and art that is not original work....absolutely no apologies there kid.
Give me fuel! Give me fire! Give me the same 4 kaiju artists or I retire
If we're at the point where people are bitching the 50s comic inspired comic looks like a 50s comic, we're royally fucked.
Thank god nobody from this fandom has any sort of power. We'd still be on Rulers of Earth and it's middling story rather than these experimental and fun takes on Godzilla.
A bit unhinged today, aren't we?
If depends honestly....if
Monsters & Protectors-All Hail the King/Skate or Die/GvsMMPRII/War For Humanity/Rivals VS Round 3 are the most common by-products/results of the "let's throw every whacky idea against the wall" approach, then you're damn right I'll take
ROE any day over the above.
Also, since *every* single mini lately has been a "off the wall the idea", we actually haven't had a straight-up, good ol' fashioned kaiju series lately (aside froma handful of
Rivals VS Rounds 1 & 2 before that series when off the rails), which would ironically be refreshing at this point.
Of course I could point out how I quite enjoyed "outside of the box" concepts like
G&G, HTBD & SOG,
GinHell,
RAT, and the first
GvsMMPR, or despite not caring for Sicoli's artwork, that I think the concept of
Monsterpiece Theatre could potentially be quite fun, but naah...