You and I agree that a great film can be made with minimal dialogue and simplistic storytelling. My favorite film of the decade is Mad Max: Fury Road, which is basically just one long car chase with very little dialogue. And I really do think 1917 was great, just not as great as Parasite. I would argue that, in general, a film with well-developed characters and a layered story is better than a film with simple characters and a simple story, but that's certainly not always the case.Chrispy_G wrote:For me....it was like many films that have won Best Picture in the last 10 years, you watch them once....say "oh that was good", and then never really feel compelled to watch them again. That's just my opinion.HedorahIsBestGirl wrote:Why is Parasite overrated? I like 1917 a lot, too, but I think Parasite absolutely deserved the Oscar. Phenomenal writing, acting and directing, original story, seamless blend of comedy and tragedy. 1917 was an immersive experience with fantastic cinematography, but the actual plot and characters were paper-thin; Parasite's plot and characters were rich and engrossing.Chrispy_G wrote:I found Parasite to be really over-rated, definitely don't think it deserved Best Picture.
Also....something doesn't have to be complex to be of a very high quality. Some of the best films and shows are actually simple. There is 100% a place for minimalism...and minimalism does not exclude artistry.
Look at Primal, not a spoken line of dialogue...but that doesn't make it any less of a masterpiece. Gravity had essentially 2 characters and the experience was no less exciting.
There is a place for purity and minimalism...and truly amazing cinema can still be achieved while embracing both. Complexity and depth is not inherently superior, or required for a superior piece of cinema
I agree with your assessment of most of the 2010s Best Picture winners, which is exactly why I challenged your views on Parasite. I think Parasite broke the mold by being the first Best Picture winner since The Hurt Locker that I found truly thought-provoking and am eager to watch again.